Revised FCC Debt Collection Processes for Delinquent Support Fund Obligations Shift Burdens to Carriers

The FCC recently announced revisions to its debt collection process for those carriers that are delinquent in contributing to the FCC’s Universal Service Fund (“USF”), Telecommunications Relay Services Fund (“TRS”) and North American Numbering Plan Fund (“NANP”) (collectively the “Funds”). Under the new procedures, the Fund administrators will forward delinquent accounts directly to the United States Department of Treasury (“Treasury”) for collection (where a 28% collection fee is added), rather than forwarding them to the FCC first. In addition, the FCC will no longer send delinquency notices to contributors for these types of debts.

These revisions could have a significant impact on telecommunications providers, who now may receive only a single notice before an outstanding debt is transferred to Treasury for collection. Contributors will have to exercise greater diligence to ensure that they receive notices of delinquent obligations to the Funds and do not mistakenly incur collection fees.
 

Under the prior debt collection process, contributors that failed to make required Fund contributions would receive a notice (and sometimes several) from the Fund’s administrator explaining the potential consequences of failing to pay a debt.  Delinquent debts eventually would be transferred by the Fund administrator to the FCC for collection.  The FCC would then place the entity on “red light” status.  While attempting to collect the debt, the FCC would send delinquency notices to the contributor, including, typically, a courtesy notice sent shortly before a debt was to be transferred to Treasury.  If the FCC’s collection efforts were unsuccessful, the FCC would transfer the debts to Treasury.  A fee equal to a percentage of the outstanding debt amount - currently set at 28% - is added to debts transferred to Treasury. 

Under the new debt collection process, Fund administrators will bypass the Commission and transfer debts directly to Treasury.  Fund administrators are only required to send one notice to a contributor explaining the consequences of failing to pay a delinquent debt.  Thus, while some Fund administrators may continue to issue multiple delinquency notices (at 30, 60 and 90 days), this is not required.  Moreover, the FCC will no longer send its own notices before debts are transferred to Treasury.  Consequently, contributors that miss the Fund administrator’s debt delinquency notice may later find their debts have been transferred to Treasury without further warning.
 

It should be noted that the FCC’s announcement did not mention the Local Number Portability Administration (“LNPA”) Fund.  Carriers should expect that debts owed to that fund will continue to be collected pursuant to the existing debt collection process.  However, we anticipate that this may change in the near future resulting in the LNPA following the new debt collection process.   


What this means for carriers:
 

There is now an increased chance that a Fund debt delinquency notice that “falls through the cracks” may turn into an expensive headache.   

  • Timely response to a Fund debt delinquency notice is critical.  Do not ignore a Fund’s debt notice because it may be the only notice received before a debt is transferred to Treasury.
     
  • Carriers should ensure that the contact address available to the Fund administrator is accurate and that the persons receiving such notice are properly trained to respond.  Failure to pay debts has legal consequences including FCC “red light” application processing holds.  In our experience, the FCC notice often was an important backstop, because this was sent to the contact address listed for official FCC correspondence, rather than the Fund’s contact person.  The FCC's contact person often was a regulatory or legal contact outside the department that ordinarily handles revenue reporting or accounts payable. 

  • Carriers also should regularly check the FCC’s Red Light Display system.  Fund administrators report contributor debt delinquencies to the Commission on a daily basis.  Frequent checks to the FCC’s Red Light Display system will provide another alert of the existence of delinquent Fund contribution debts.  Note: Checking the Red Light Display system is particularly important as once on "red light" status, contributors are prevented from conducting new business before the Commission and the Commission withholds action on the contributor’s outstanding requests, such as applications or petitions.

 

FCC Releases 2012 Universal Service Revenue Reporting Worksheet

As it does every year, the FCC released its update to the annual Form 499-A.  The Form 499-A is used to report revenues for purposes of the federal Universal Service Fund and also for calculating associated revenue-based contribution obligations such as TRS, NANP, LNP and FCC Regulatory Fees.  The Public Notice describes changes to the form, primarily to implement the new requirement that non-interconnected VoIP providers contribute to the TRS fund.  (Non-interconnected VoIP providers were required to register with USAC for this purpose by December 31, 2011.)

The 2012 Form 499-A has been posted on USAC's website.  Go to "universal service links" in our Resource Center on the right-hand side of this page for the USAC Forms page.

REMINDER:  Kelley Drye will discuss these changes, important developments in USF audits and other topics at our 3rd Annual USF Update Webinar next week.  This is our most popular webinar of the year.  Please register today. 

Reminder: Non-Interconnected VoIP Providers Must Register by December 31

Back in October, the FCC released an order implementing the Twenty-First Century Communications and Video Accessibility Act of 2010 (CVAA).  Among other things, the order expanded the pool of contributors to the Telecommunications Relay Service Fund to include virtually all VoIP providers, including those that did not fit the FCC's definition of "interconnected" VoIP.

To implement this contribution requirement, non-interconnected VoIP providers are required to register with the FCC by filing FCC Form 499-A, which is better known as the form used for universal service fund contributions.  (The Form 499-A is used for other revenue-based support funds as well.)  Providers must file this form no later than December 31, 2011.  At this time, it appears that fewer than a dozen new providers have registered to date.  

For the FCC's CVAA order, see this link. A non-interconnected VoIP provider offers a service that (i) enables real-time voice communications that originate from or terminate to the user’s location using Internet protocol or any successor protocol and (ii) requires Internet protocol compatible customer premises equipment, but (iii) is not an interconnected VoIP service.

VoIP service providers should consult with their counsel to determine whether this new requirement reaches their activities.  

VoIP Coalition Warns of Excessive Regulation

In late May, the Voice on the Net Coalition ("VON") held a series of meetings with FCC Commissioner's offices concerning VoIP regulations.  The Coalition discussed topics affecting 21 pending FCC dockets, and, according to the summary of the meetings, "expressed concern that additional regulation of the IP communications industry could deter investment and innovation ..."  The Coalition opposed a variety of new regulations:

  • The Coalition opposed imposition of intercarrier compensation obligations to VoIP and argued for bill and keep for VoIP traffic;
  • The Coalition opposed using advertising revenues to assess TRS obligations on VoIP providers;
  • The Coalition opposed requirements to file broadband deployment reports (Form 477) and to apply FCC billing rules to VoIP;
  • The Coalition urged a narrow interpretation of new disability access requirements and supported "broad waivers" of such rules; and
  • The Coalition opposed the opening of a rulemaking to require E911 for mobile VoIP applications.

The Coalition also attached a chart summarizing FCC actions to regulate interconnected VoIP services.  The chart mirrors the summary we prepared back in November of the regulatory obligations of VoIP services.  VON's summary chart identifies 8 pending proceedings proposing to add regulatory obligations to VoIP service providers and details 13 previous FCC orders regulating VoIP services.  Since the Coalition prepared its chart, the FCC added one more proposed obligation:  a proposal to require interconnected VoIP providers to report their international traffic and revenues.  See Kelley Drye's Client Advisory on the international reporting obligations for more details.